Columbia Journalism Review Fail

Matthew Hoy
By Matthew Hoy on May 20, 2013

The Columbia Journalism Review's tagline is "The future of media is here." If it is, then journalism is in worse shape than it appears—and that takes some doing.

In the days following Kirsten Power's "Come to Jesus" column calling out the mainstream media for its failure I pointed out to a shocked Mollie Hemingway of on Twitter that the Big 3 media criticism sites: Poynter, CJR and Jim Romenesko had all maintained radio silence on the issue. It reinforced the criticism of many on the right that even the self-appointed media watchdogs are too cozy with the journalists they cover.

Today, when the news broke that the Obama Justice Department had named Fox News Channel James Rosen a co-conspirator in a plot to violate the Espionage Act by doing something called reporting, I checked the usual suspects. Romenesko had a brief post with links.  Poynter had a more extensive brief with lots of good quotes and links. And CJR responded with absolutely zero commentary on the site. The top three "Must-Reads From Around the Web" are all about the Rosen case, but no original reporting. Or did they?

Columbia Journalism Review
Columbia Journalism Review

The article that picture links to is here. It refers to the Benghazi, IRS and Associated Press phone records scandals, but not today's Rosen revelations. I realize one shouldn't impute malice when mere incompetence can explain it, but what the heck is going on at CJR? What are they suggesting?

Does anybody know what's going on around here?


When Everytown, Giffords and others describe states like CA, NY, and NJ as having the best gun control laws in the country, but then say those gun laws are still way too weak, they are giving away their endgame. Full bans of most (if not all) of civilian owned firearms.

Konstadinos Moros@MorosKostas

Stronger gun laws? Bro this is what the organization you fund says about New York.

Load More...


May 2013



pencil linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram