Cow manure

Matthew Hoy
By Matthew Hoy on December 20, 2007

Time managing editor Adi Ignatius on that magazine's selection of Vladimir Putin as "Person of the Year":

"It's not an honor ... we're not saying that he's a good person, we're not saying he's a bad person. He is the person who has most affected the news in 2007 and going forward."

Nos. 2-5 were:
2. Al Gore
3. J.K. Rowling
4. Hu Jintao
5. Gen. David Petraeus

By Ignatius' standard, there's absolutely no -- zippo, zero, zilch -- way that Putin belongs at #1. You could make a better case for Gore and his global warming alarmism. Rowling and Jintao don't fit either.

And Petraeus? Well, if the yardstick is "who has most affected the news in 2007 and going forward," Petraeus is hard to beat. I'd be shocked if the results of a Lexis-Nexis search of 2007 Time issues up to the Person of the Year issue mentioned Putin one-tenth of the times it mentioned Petraeus.

What a load of manure.

0 comments on “Cow manure”

  1. I disagree. Gore, Rowling(!) and Hu Jintao probably wouldn't even make my list at all. Petraeus might make my list but while his role is talked about often it is still a role that time will tell his success (and for some any violence will be reason enough to cry defeat).

    Internal Russian politics have been in the news : assassinations, arrests etc. Putin controls much of Europe's natural gas and Europe's overland access to asia and has taken a destabilizing role against the Republic of Georgia. I haven't kept up with its relationship with other former Soviet states. But consider that Russia still has UN veto(and isn't shy about threatening to use it), is building (or has built) Iran's Bushehr nuclear power plant, is shipping nuclear fuel to Iran and seems to be playing the west and Iran against each other for the sake of it... Imagine if he announced that any attack against Iran would provoke an unspecified response from Russia. Russia still has ICBMs and would make me very uneasy if they became belligerent or even threatened belligerence. Sure, he isn't crazy but he could doubtlessly gain concessions. Like it or not, what Putin decides with regard to Iran and Russia's role in the world will be important.

Tags

[custom-twitter-feeds headertext="Hoystory On Twitter"]

Calendar

December 2007
M T W T F S S
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Archives

Categories

pencil
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram